• Home
  • Blog
  • Shaving Soap vs Shaving Cream for Safety Razors

Shaving Soap vs Shaving Cream for Safety Razors


When it comes to wet shaving with safety razors, the debate between shaving soap and shaving cream has been ongoing for many years and through many generations. Both options have their merits and can improve your shaving experience, but which one should you choose? In this comprehensive guide, we'll dive deep into the world of wet shaving and help you make an informed decision between these two essential grooming products.

The Basics: Shaving Soap and Shaving Cream Defined

Shaving Soap: A Time-Honoured Tradition

Shaving soap, is most associated with classic barber shops and traditional wet shaving. For many men it is a tried-and-true grooming essential. It comes in various forms, including hard pucks, and sticks. 

Shaving soap is known for its rich lather and the luxurious experience it provides. This product is typically used with a shaving brush. It does require a bit more time and effort to achieve the perfect lather compared to shaving cream.

It remains the more traditional choice.

no 5 rated shaving soap

Shaving Cream: Convenience at Your Fingertips

Shaving cream, on the other hand, is the go-to choice for those seeking a quick and hassle-free shave. It's available in tubes, or tubs, making it incredibly convenient to use. 

Shaving cream is known for its ease of application; simply dispense the cream and lather it onto your face with your hands.

It's ideal for those looking for a fast and efficient shaving experience. You can also apply shaving cream with a shaving brush.

tub of shaving cream

Differences in the Lathering Process Explained

Shaving Soap: The Art of the Lather

Using shaving soap is an art in itself and will take a little bit of practise to get it 100% right. To create a rich and creamy lather, you'll need to soak your shaving brush in warm water, shake off excess water, and then swirl it vigorously over the soap.

As mentioned, this process can take a bit of practice, but once you master it, the lather produced is exceptionally thick and provides excellent lubrication for your safety razor. Shaving soap enthusiasts appreciate the ritualistic aspect of this method.

Shaving Cream: Speed and Convenience

Shaving cream enthusiasts, on the other hand, enjoy the convenience it offers. With just a small amount of cream, you can quickly create a lather directly on your face.

This method is perfect for those with a busy lifestyle or those new to wet shaving. The lather may not be as dense as that of shaving soap, but it still provides a smooth and comfortable shave.

Skin Types and Sensitivities

Shaving Soap Benefits: Ideal for Tough Beards and Sensitive Skin

Shaving soap is often the preferred choice for individuals with thick, coarse facial hair or sensitive skin. Its thicker lather provides a protective cushion between the safety razor blade and your skin, reducing the risk of irritation. Additionally, many shaving soaps are formulated with natural ingredients that are gentle on the skin.

Unlike the instant lather of shaving cream, shaving soap requires a bit of effort. You'll need a good quality shaving brush and a bit of practice to create a rich, thick lather. But the process is part of the charm for many traditionalists. The thick lather produced by shaving soap cushions your skin, allowing for a closer and more precise shave. This can be especially beneficial if you have a thicker beard or desire a more refined result.

Shaving soaps often contain natural ingredients such as shea butter, coconut oil, and essential oils. These components nourish your skin and leave it feeling refreshed and rejuvenated post-shave.

Shaving Cream Benefits : Versatile and Hydrating

Shaving cream is a versatile option suitable for a wide range of skin types. It's especially beneficial for individuals with dry or dehydrated skin, as many shaving creams contain moisturising ingredients. If you prefer a more hydrating and lightweight lather, shaving cream might be the better choice for you.

Shaving cream gives an instant lather and dispenses a rich, creamy lather instantly. This luxurious lather provides a smooth glide for your razor, making it an excellent choice for those with busy mornings. The best quality shaving creams often contain moisturising ingredients like aloe vera and glycerin. These components help keep your skin hydrated throughout the shave, reducing the risk of irritation and dryness.

Shaving cream can be used with both cartridge razors, straight razors and safety razors, making it a versatile choice for all types of shavers. This adaptability is one of the reasons it's a favourite among many men.

Fragrance and Aroma Differences

Shaving Soap: Aromatic Bliss

One of the charming aspects of shaving soap is the wide variety of fragrances available. You can find shaving soaps with scents ranging from classic sandalwood and citrus to unique and exotic aromas. The aromatic experience adds a sensory delight to your morning routine.

Shaving Cream: Pleasantly Scented Convenience

Shaving creams also come in an array of delightful scents, making your shaving experience more enjoyable. Whether you prefer a traditional scent or a contemporary fragrance, shaving creams offer a pleasant olfactory experience without the need for a separate aftershave.

Environmental Impact

Shaving Soap: Eco-Friendly Choice

For environmentally conscious individuals, shaving soap is often the more sustainable choice. It usually comes in recyclable packaging. By choosing shaving soap, you're contributing to a greener planet.

Shaving Cream: Convenient, but Less Eco-Friendly

Shaving cream, while convenient, can generate more waste due to its packaging. If you're looking to reduce your environmental footprint, shaving soap is the better option.

Our Final Verdict and Opinion

In the end, the choice between shaving soap and shaving cream for your safety razor comes down to personal preference and your shaving routine. If you value the time-honoured tradition of wet shaving and appreciate the art of creating a rich lather, shaving soap is your best bet. On the other hand, if convenience and speed are your top priorities, shaving cream is the way to go.

Remember, there's no one-size-fits-all answer, and it's perfectly acceptable to try both options to see which suits you best. Whichever you choose, the most important thing is to enjoy your shaving experience and achieve the smooth, clean shave you desire.

About the Author

Follow me

Thanks for visiting the Shaving Emporium website. This is a shaving website aimed at readers in the UK and Ireland. We are experienced experts and have included lots of information about shaving and grooming, and we have also completed detailed research that helps us write our product reviews. We like to have our information as up to date as possible.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}